Quarterback: Eli Manning, NYG – Probably the easiest decision to make on the list, he was the main reason for two critical wins over the Cowboys. Manning threw for 400 yards to rally the Giants from 12 down to beat Dallas in the first game, one that probably shaped the season for both clubs, and then in the winner-take-all finale, he passed for 334 yards and three scores to lift the Giants to the playoffs and eventually the Super Bowl.
Running Back: LeSean McCoy, PHI – He arguably had the best game of any one player against the Cowboys, especially on offense. While McCoy didn't hurt them much in the second meeting, it was the first contest, when he ripped through the Cowboys for 185 rushing yards and two touchdowns, that has him on this list.
